Millions of American women look up to stars who promote various types of weight loss food plans and drinks but experts say these aren’t the healthiest options.
Celebrities from all walks of life have used their social media platforms to promote the latest weight loss diet products. These products include everything from detox teas to meal replacement shakes, but are these drinks actually healthy for you? HollywoodLife spoke EXCLUSIVELY with two experts who answered that question. Nutritionist and personal trainer, Amanda Carneiro, warned that these products may simply be a “marketing gimmick.”
“Many of the flat tummy and slimming teas products being promoted are just expensive formulations of teas that have a natural mild laxative effect. It’s just a marketing gimmick!” Carneiro said. “I think the use of these teas can send the wrong message and set young girls and even women down a path to an unhealthy relationship with food and their bodies, or looking for a quick fix to weight loss.” Women of all ages look up to stars like the Kardashians who promote brands including Flat Tummy and Teami Blends but Carneiro said there’s “no magic tea that’s going to fix a poor diet and lifestyle.”
We also questioned certified holistic health coach, Kristin Kilmer, who told us EXCLUSIVELY that, “If the intestines are compromised with leaky gut or autoimmune issues such as Crohn’s disease, high doses of the teas could cause more irritation which could also lead to mal-absorbed nutrients.” However, Kilmer added that “a lot of these herbs alone have good nutritional properties. Most of the ingredients are actually pretty healthy and safe. The ‘controversial’ ingredient is Senna leaf because it acts as a laxative and for some people, they can become dependent on it and their bowels stop functioning normally.”
Carneiro fears that some women could develop eating disorders if they rely on these diet drinks for their nutrition. Carneiro explained, “Healthy and sustainable weight loss is achievable, but these teas, no matter how much you drink, aren’t going to magically make anyone slimmer or fitter. Only a healthy diet and lifestyle can do that.” Kilmer agreed and added, “If a person is inclined to an eating disorder they may try to take the tea alone without proper healthy meals which could lead to a binge later.”
Meal replacement shakes made headlines when The Good Place actress and body positivity activist, Jameela Jamil, 33, slammed Khloe Kardashian, 34, for a March 20 post in which the mom-of-one showed off a pink lacy bra and skintight jeans while flaunting her “flat tummy.” Khloe credited the Flat Tummy meal replacement shakes for her incredible figure in her caption and said “the progress is undeniable.”
Jameela shaded the reality star and said, “If you’re too irresponsible to: a own up to the fact that you have a personal trainer, nutritionist, probable chef, and a surgeon to achieve your aesthetic, rather than this laxative product… And b tell them the side effects of this NON-FDA approved product, that most doctors are saying aren’t healthy,” and added that “she’d have to” include the side effects. “Possible Flat Tummy Tea side effects are cramping, stomach pains, diarrhea, and dehydration,” Jameela informed Khloe fans.
Carneiro agreed that diet teas “if used in large quantities can cause dehydration which can lead to serious health issues. Not to mention, these herbs could cause bloating, abdominal pain, gas, and nausea, which isn’t very fun. Many of these teas also contain a high amount of caffeine, which can cause anxiety, restlessness, and sleep disturbances, which is one of the worst things for fat loss. However, used in moderation they are generally safe.”